American Versus European Food: Which is Better? Part 3

Disclaimer: I love the USA—seriously, I wouldn’t have spent over $30,000 on my O1 visa and green card if I didn’t! Now I’m not suggesting there aren’t healthy people in the UK. Really, there are loads! I mean, I live in California, one of the most bodylicious states in the world, So I know healthy lifestyles when I see them—whether it’s through natural choices, store-bought solutions, or even real versus questionable supplements. This is not about bashing anyone’s habits; it’s just about pointing out some of the fascinating food differences between these two regions. No offense intended—let’s keep it fun!

Welcome back, dear readers of What’s in the Middle! Having spent a jolly good 16 years in the land of stars and stripes, I’ve had plenty of time to mull over the culinary quirks between American and European fare. Spoiler alert: it’s been a right old adventure for my taste buds.

In this final installment, we’re venturing into the why behind these differences. What drives the contrasting approaches to food production, safety, and regulation? Let’s dig in!

The Regulatory Divide: Caution vs. Freedom

At the heart of the differences in food quality between the US and Europe is a fundamental difference in regulatory philosophy. Europe takes the precautionary principle: if there’s evidence that something might be harmful, it’s banned or heavily restricted. The US, on the other hand, adopts an innocent-until-proven-guilty approach, allowing many additives, chemicals, and GMOs unless they are definitively proven to cause harm.

For example:

Artificial Colors: The EU has strict regulations on food dyes like Yellow 6 and Red 40, requiring warning labels if they’re used. Many manufacturers simply avoid them altogether. In the US, these dyes are widely used without warnings.
Growth Hormones: Banned in Europe due to concerns over human health, but common in US beef and dairy production.
Pesticides: The EU bans over 1,300 pesticides, while the US restricts far fewer. Glyphosate, a controversial herbicide, is widely used in the US but heavily restricted in Europe.

This regulatory gap is driven by cultural attitudes: Europe prioritizes caution, while the US emphasizes innovation and economic growth.

The Hidden Impact of Subsidies

Another major factor in the US food system is agricultural subsidies. The US government heavily subsidizes crops like corn, soy, and wheat. While this keeps food prices low, it also encourages the overproduction of these crops, leading to their presence in nearly every processed food item.

Ever wondered why high-fructose corn syrup is so ubiquitous in the US? Subsidies make corn incredibly cheap, and manufacturers use it as a cost-effective sweetener. Europe, on the other hand, doesn’t subsidize corn on the same scale, which is why you’re less likely to find high-fructose corn syrup in European foods.

Farm-to-Table: A Cultural Contrast

In Europe, local food markets and small-scale farms remain central to the food culture. From French farmers’ markets to Italian olive groves, there’s a deep connection to where food comes from. Seasonal eating is the norm, and many people still prioritize fresh, locally-sourced ingredients.

In the US, while the farm-to-table movement is growing, much of the food system is dominated by large-scale industrial agriculture. The sheer size of the country makes it harder to focus on local, seasonal eating, and convenience often takes priority.

Example:

A baguette bought at a French market was likely baked that morning with local flour.
A loaf of bread from an American supermarket was probably produced locally, as the majority of bread consumed in the US is domestically produced.

The Role of Marketing in Food Choices

Let’s talk about how marketing influences what we eat. In the US, food companies spend billions on advertising, particularly targeting children. Brightly colored cereal boxes, flashy fast-food ads, and cartoon characters on packaging make processed foods nearly irresistible. Meanwhile, in Europe, stricter advertising regulations limit the marketing of unhealthy foods, especially to kids.

Fun Fact: Did you know that the EU bans ads for sugary foods during children’s programming? In the US, you’ll see ads for candy bars and fast food sandwiched between episodes of SpongeBob.

The Cost of Eating Healthy

One of the starkest differences is the cost of healthy food. In the US, fresh fruits, vegetables, and organic options are often more expensive than processed, calorie-dense foods. In Europe, governments tend to subsidize healthy foods or tax unhealthy ones, making it easier for people to make better choices.

Example:

In the UK, a "sugar tax" has reduced the sugar content in sodas and sweetened drinks.
In the US, sodas are often cheaper than bottled water.

This cost disparity plays a major role in the higher rates of obesity and diet-related illnesses in the US.

Cultural Attitudes Toward Food

Finally, let’s talk about mindset. In Europe, food is often viewed as a pleasure, not just fuel. Meals are leisurely, communal, and savored. In the US, the hustle culture means food is often fast, convenient, and eaten on the go.

This cultural difference shapes the entire food system:

In Italy, a simple meal of pasta, fresh vegetables, and olive oil is a celebration of quality ingredients.
In the US, convenience foods like frozen dinners and drive-thru burgers reflect a focus on efficiency.

Neither approach is inherently wrong—they’re just different ways of prioritizing what matters most in daily life.

Final Thoughts

As we wrap up this series, it’s clear that American and European food systems are shaped by deeply rooted cultural and regulatory philosophies. The US prioritizes convenience, cost, and innovation, while Europe leans into tradition, quality, and caution. Neither system is perfect, but understanding the differences can help us make more informed choices—no matter where we live.

Thank you for joining me on this food journey through What’s in the Middle! Whether you’re savoring a baguette in Paris or biting into a veggie burger in California, here’s to celebrating food in all its delicious, quirky forms.

Cheers until next time!

What's in the middle

Search This Blog